Quick Summary:
Research on generations in the workplace shows that labels such as Gen Z or Baby Boomer are weak predictors of how employees work, communicate, or learn. Those differences are generally small, while career stage, experience, culture, and individual circumstances explain far more. For learning and development leaders, that means treating a request for generational training as a performance question first, designing leadership and communication training around a thorough audience analysis rather than age-based assumptions, and teaching managers to ask questions instead of relying on stereotypes.
“That’s just how Gen Z is.”
It’s an easy explanation when a younger employee approaches work differently than an experienced colleague. Maybe they question an established process, prefer a different communication style, or have different expectations of their manager.
But what if their age isn’t the reason?
For learning and development (L&D) leaders, assumptions about generations can influence everything from leadership training to how organizations communicate with employees. The challenge is that a generational label doesn’t tell you much about what an individual needs to succeed.
Research backs this up. Studies have found that differences in workplace attitudes between generations are generally small, while factors such as career stage, experience, and individual circumstances can offer more useful explanations.
Employees across generations in the workplace still bring different experiences and perspectives, so the first step is understanding what’s driving those differences before deciding how to address them.
When it comes to developing people, curiosity is more useful than categorization. And that starts with understanding what research actually tells us about generations in the workplace.
Are generational differences in the workplace real?
People from different generations in the workplace often have different experiences, responsibilities, and perspectives. The challenge is determining whether those differences are caused by generation.
Research suggests that generational labels are much less useful for understanding workplace attitudes than popular discussions might lead us to believe.
A 2020 report from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, Are Generational Categories Meaningful Distinctions for Workforce Management?, concluded that categorizing workers by generation is not supported by research and cannot adequately inform workforce management decisions.
Other research points in the same direction:
- Costanza and colleagues (2012): A meta-analysis of 20 studies involving 19,961 workers examined job satisfaction, organizational commitment, and intent to leave. Generational differences were small or near zero in nearly every case.
- Rudolph and colleagues (2021): These researchers advocated a lifespan development perspective as a better way to understand age and work than relying on generational stereotypes.
- Pew Research Center (2023): After a year-long review, Pew said it would use generational analysis only when comparing generations at similar life stages. It also emphasized the considerable diversity of thought and behavior within each generation.
Together, these findings challenge the idea that knowing someone’s generation tells you much about how they prefer to work, communicate, or learn.
Consider two employees: one is 25 and the other is 55. Their differences might reflect career experience, job responsibilities, familiarity with a particular technology, or the circumstances of their lives. Those differences don’t automatically mean they belong to fundamentally different workplace cultures.
This is an important distinction for learning and development teams. If you assume a learner’s needs based on age, you may design a solution for a problem that doesn’t exist or overlook the actual reason someone is struggling.
Why generational differences are difficult to measure
Researchers face a fundamental challenge when comparing generations: age, birth year, and the time in which someone lives are closely connected.
Imagine comparing a 25-year-old employee with a 55-year-old colleague today. They differ in age, career stage, and the historical experiences they’ve lived through. They are also navigating the same current workplace, economic conditions, and technological changes.
How can researchers determine which factor explains a particular difference?
The National Academies report highlights the difficulty of separating these age, period, and generation effects. A preference that appears to be generational may instead reflect someone’s stage of life or career.
For example, an employee early in their career may need more guidance navigating workplace expectations. An experienced employee may want greater autonomy. But those preferences aren’t exclusive to specific generations. People of different ages can share similar needs, and those needs can change over time.
Sociologist Karl Mannheim explored this complexity in his 1928 essay, The Problem of Generations. He argued that formative historical events influence people’s worldviews, while also recognizing that people who experience the same events can respond in opposing ways.
Popular frameworks for generations in the workplace often lose that nuance. They turn broad observations about historical experiences into profiles that suggest everyone born within a particular period shares the same attitudes.
In practice, an individual’s perspective is shaped by much more than a birth year.
What shapes employees beyond their generation?
For learning and development leaders, several factors can provide more useful context than a generational label.
1. Formative experiences
Wars, recessions, technological changes, and major news events can influence how people view the world. But people interpret those experiences differently, even when they live through the same events.
2. Family and upbringing
Family expectations and the experiences of parents and caregivers can influence how people approach education, work, and responsibility. Those influences vary considerably from one person to another.
3. Country and culture
Employees who grew up in different countries may have different expectations about authority, collaboration, communication, and professional development. Applying a framework built primarily around U.S. experiences to a global workforce can overlook those differences.
4. Region and community
Even within one country, growing up in a rural community or a major city can provide different experiences, opportunities, and cultural reference points.
5. Career and life stage
An employee’s role, tenure, industry, responsibilities, and personal circumstances can affect what they need from their employer. A 45-year-old changing careers and a 23-year-old entering the workforce may have similar onboarding needs despite their age difference.
Research on work values reinforces this point. A study examining employees in the United States, Russia, India, and Argentina found differences between Millennial and Generation X work values only in the United States, the most individualistic culture in the sample.
Similarly, a survey of 1,019 employees in the United States and Turkey found little evidence of meaningful generational differences and concluded that U.S. generational categories did not generalize to the Turkish business context.
A study of 1,188 Generation Z students in China, Germany, the Netherlands, and Thailand found that nationality was an important differentiator in work values. Learning and visible results were the only two values that appealed across all four groups.
Research on Millennials has also identified age, gender, relationship status, and nationality as factors shaping work values and preferences.
The takeaway is that generational identity and no other single label can account for the many experiences and circumstances that shape an employee’s perspective.
How generational stereotypes can
undermine leadership training
Generational content often enters leadership development with good intentions. An organization wants managers to communicate more effectively, understand colleagues with different perspectives, and build stronger teams.
The problem begins when training presents broad generalizations about generations in the workplace as reliable descriptions of individual employees.
The National Academies warns that generational categories can contribute to workplace prejudice, bias, and stereotyping. Research on age stereotypes illustrates how assumptions can affect employees at both ends of the age spectrum.
Younger workers may be treated as inexperienced or automatically assumed to be digital natives. Older workers may face jokes about their ability to use technology or assumptions that they’re preparing to retire.
Neither approach helps managers understand what an individual can contribute or what support they need.
For L&D leaders, or a learning and development consultant brought in to review a leadership development program, the more useful question is whether that content helps participants behave differently in useful ways.
Ask yourself:
- Will participants learn how to navigate an actual workplace conversation more effectively?
- Does the content encourage them to ask questions, or does it teach them to make assumptions about people they haven’t met?
- Would employees from different countries and cultural backgrounds recognize themselves in the examples?
- Could the same learning objective be achieved by teaching communication skills that work across age groups?
If a module teaches managers that one generation prefers instant messages while another prefers phone calls, participants may leave with a new set of assumptions rather than a better way to communicate.
A more useful lesson teaches managers how to discover each person’s preferences and adapt accordingly.
Lead with curiosity instead of assumption
One of the most practical ways to strengthen communication across a multigenerational workforce is to replace assumptions with genuine curiosity.
That doesn’t require an elaborate training program. It starts with how people respond to one another in everyday conversations.
Here are three techniques worth practicing.
Repeat a few of the other person’s words.
Former FBI hostage negotiator Chris Voss describes this technique as mirroring: repeating the last one to three words someone has said to encourage them to continue.
If a colleague says, “That process slows everyone down,” you might respond, “Slows everyone down?”
The response invites the person to explain their thinking rather than immediately defending the existing process.
Acknowledge the perspective and ask for more information.
Try, “That’s an interesting perspective. Can you share your thinking behind it?”
This gives the other person room to explain their reasoning without requiring you to agree with them.
Give yourself time to process.
Not every comment needs an immediate response. If you’re unsure what to say, try, “Let me sit with that for a minute.”
Pausing can help you avoid responding based on an initial assumption.
The key is to ask questions that genuinely invite an answer. “Do you feel that way because you’re new to the workforce?” may sound like a question, but it already suggests an explanation. “What led you to that perspective?” leaves room for the person to tell you.
Here’s how that distinction can play out at work:
|
Workplace situation
|
Instead of assuming…
|
Try asking…
|
|---|---|---|
Rolling out new software |
"You'll pick this up fast. You grew up with this stuff." |
"How do you usually like to learn a new tool?" |
A colleague prefers phone calls to chat messages |
"That's a generational thing." |
"What makes calling work better for you?" |
A newer employee questions an established process |
"You haven't been here long enough to understand why we do it this way." |
"What led you to that perspective?" |
Discussing an experienced employee's career |
"Are you starting to think about retirement?" |
"What do you want the next few years of your career to look like?" |
A teammate sets limits on after-hours messages |
"Your generation doesn't want to put in the time." |
"Can you share more about what's working and what isn't for you?" |
These conversations help managers understand individual preferences without attributing them to age. They also create opportunities to uncover issues that generational assumptions might obscure.
Designing training for a multigenerational workforce
The same principle applies when a stakeholder asks for training specifically for younger employees, older workers, or another age-defined group.
Rather than starting with a generational profile, start with an audience analysis.
Audience Analysis in Instructional Design:
The National Academies recommends that employers assess their work environments, job requirements, and workforce needs when making management decisions, and revisit those decisions regularly.
For learning designers and program owners, that means investigating the performance or learning need before deciding who the training is for and how it should be delivered.
Consider these questions:
- Roles and responsibilities: What do employees need to do, and what needs to change about their performance?
- Tenure and experience: Are learners new to the organization, new to a role, or experienced in the work but unfamiliar with a particular process?
- Locations and languages: Do cultural references, language requirements, or regional differences affect the learning experience?
- Work conditions: Are employees desk-based or frontline? Do they have reliable access to devices and dedicated time for learning?
- Prior learning experiences: What training formats have learners used before, and which have helped them apply new skills?
The stakeholder’s request may point to a legitimate business need. Perhaps managers are struggling to communicate with newer team members, or employees need support adopting a new technology.
The next step is to determine what’s driving that need. Is it related to job experience, unclear expectations, access to technology, the design of the learning experience, or something else?
Is the training request really a performance question?
A request for training aimed at one generation can be a sign of a performance gap: the business expects results it isn’t seeing, and age is the easiest explanation at hand. Performance consulting starts with that gap. A performance consultant compares what people are doing with what the business needs, identifies the causes, and then recommends the fix, which might be training, a job aid, a process change, or clearer expectations.
A thorough audience analysis helps L&D teams answer those questions before investing in a solution. It also helps ensure that training reflects the people who will use it, rather than a generalized profile of their age group. If your team doesn’t have the capacity to run that analysis, a learning and development consultant can gather the data and bring an outside perspective to the request.
Sometimes the analysis shows the real issue is a shift in roles, tools, or processes rather than a skills gap. When employees are struggling to adopt a new system, a restructured team, or a new way of working, a change management consultant can assess how the change affects different groups, reduce resistance, and support adoption, so the problem isn’t mistaken for a generational one.
Four ways to build connection
across generations in the workplace
Training is only one part of creating a workplace where employees with different experiences can work effectively together. Organizations can also create opportunities for colleagues to learn from one another.
Pair employees with different experiences.
Cross-mentoring and reverse mentoring can help employees exchange knowledge. Consider differences in tenure, role, technical expertise, and organizational experience rather than pairing people solely by age. Both participants should have something to contribute.
Make expectations specific.
Ambiguous instructions can create misunderstandings regardless of generation. Imagine a manager who tells a new employee to wear black pants on their first day. The manager pictures trousers; the employee arrives in black leggings. Both interpreted the instruction differently.
Clear expectations reduce the need for employees to guess what a manager means.
Create opportunities to get to know one another.
Shared projects, informal conversations, and team learning sessions give colleagues opportunities to discover common interests and understand different perspectives. Relationships develop through interaction, not simply through knowing which generation someone belongs to.
Ask how people prefer to be recognized.
Some employees appreciate public praise. Others prefer a private thank-you or an opportunity to take on a new responsibility. Asking about preferences is more reliable than assuming those preferences based on age.
These practices help organizations build connection among generations in the workplace without treating generational categories as a blueprint for employee behavior.
How TrainingPros can help
Designing effective leadership development and communication training starts with understanding the people who will participate and the workplace challenges the program needs to address.
TrainingPros is a learning and development company that connects organizations with experienced instructional designers, eLearning developers, and performance consultants. We’ve been named a Top 20 Staffing Company by Training Industry and a Champion of Learning by the Association for Talent Development (ATD), recognition that reflects our commitment to delivering high-quality, tailored learning solutions.
To hear ongoing conversations with senior learning leaders, listen to our Learning Leader Spotlight podcast:
If your learning initiatives require additional support, whether for a single project or a large-scale rollout, our relationship managers can help you find the right expertise quickly and confidently.
When you have more projects than people™, let TrainingPros find the right consultant to start your project with confidence.
Frequently asked questions
A multigenerational workforce includes employees born across several generations. Research suggests the more useful differences among them come from career stage, experience, culture, and individual circumstances, so training and management work best when they start with the individual rather than the generational label.
It can, provided the content helps participants recognize stereotypes and communicate more effectively. Training that encourages employees to profile others by generation risks reinforcing assumptions. Skills such as asking open questions, listening, and exploring different perspectives are useful across age groups.
Start with a needs analysis and your organization's workforce data. Examine job responsibilities, experience, locations, languages, work conditions, and prior learning experiences before deciding whether age is relevant to the training need.
Not necessarily. Generational language can be a conversation starter, and people may identify with the events or experiences associated with their generation. The problem arises when a broad category is used to predict how an individual thinks, behaves, communicates, or learns.
Treat it as a performance question first. Ask what results the stakeholder wants to change, then use a needs analysis to find what’s driving the gap, such as experience, unclear expectations, or access to tools. A performance consultant can run that analysis when your team lacks capacity, and the fix may be training, a job aid, or a process change.
Start by asking instead of assuming. Mirror a few of the other person’s words, acknowledge their perspective and ask what led them to a conclusion, and give yourself a moment before responding. Curiosity can reveal individual preferences that a generational label would hide.
- 0share
- LinkedIn0
- Twitter0
- Facebook0
- Love This0








